The land sparing–land sharing (SpSh) framework posited two strategies: intensifying production to “spare” land for nature, or integrating biodiversity within agricultural landscapes. Its simplifying assumptions proved ill-suited to the complexity of land systems, leading many scholars to move beyond the debate. The authors ponder if a reductionist land sparing revival has gained traction among think tanks, policy platforms and agribusiness, presenting yield maximization as a proxy for ecological and social progress. They ask if land sparing has become a “policy legend”: a socio-technical imaginary that mobilizes actors around a technocratic vision of land use, despite empirical critiques and viable alternatives. A folktale version of land sparing would narrow food system transformation, legitimizing land concentration and industrial paradigms under the guise of sustainability and foreclosing more plural and just pathways for land governance.